MattCleaver.com
youth ministry, reimagined
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact Me
  • Best Youth Ministry Books
  • Youth Ministry Book Reviews
  • Youth Ministry Blogs

Archive for Christianity – Page 2

Revisiting “Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry”

By Matt · Comments (0)
Thursday, November 15th, 2007

Yesterday, I posted on Andrew Root’s brand-new book, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry. I spoke with pretty high regard for the book, saying,

While reading the book, I came to the realization that, to my knowledge, there is no youth ministry book that is as theologically deep and rich as Root’s. Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster’s book The Godbearing Life is the only work close to Root’s in nature, but even it does not probe the depths of a particular theological subject like Root’s. In my estimation, Root’s book will be noted as being the first in a line of theological books written specifically for the context of youth ministry. With the publication of this book, a new (and needed) genre has been birthed.

Creating a new genre isn’t bad for a first book.

The reason this book excites me so much is that I believe this book is an eschatalogical event (okay, that might be a little bit of a stretch). Let me explain. Over a year ago I predicted that the next 50 years of youth ministry would see the theologizing of youth ministry. I said, among other things,

This is why I say that the theologization of youth ministry in the next 50 years will determine whether or not it will live or die. In order to be faithful to the gospel, and not bound to success, we must be able to discern when we are being faithful and when we are neutering the gospel. Among other things, theology is the practice of discernment. For those who are called as professional youth ministers, we must possess within us the ability to perceive the theological implications of everything that we do. Instead of seeing the goal and achieving it with any means possible, we must determine whether or not our means is theologically sound as well.

Yes, I do think I made that “theologization” word up.

For me, Root’s book is the expectation of the future coming to pass in the present. With Root’s book we are making the turn towards a new paradigm in youth ministry.

Yes, the book is a bit difficult to read for some; it is truly a theological work. Yes, we want to ask “but will this work?” Yes, sometimes it seems like there is a bit of practicality missing from the book.

But the reason this book might be so uncomfortable, so challenging, so unfamiliar, and so overwhelming for many of us is that we are reading it while still operating out of the current paradigm of ministry while Root is coming to the table with a completely different set of presuppositions. We would do well to listen to it diligently, since it will be our tendency to try and fit the book into our current paradigm. But to do so would be to lose the weight of the book.

This is the first book to my knowledge that is doing real theology for the sake of youth ministry. But I don’t believe it will be the last. The future of youth ministry is upon us.

Comments (0)
Categories : Best Youth Ministry Books, Book Reviews, Books, Christianity, Neo-Youth Ministry, Theology, Youth Ministry

Why Seminary?

By Matt · Comments (1)
Saturday, November 10th, 2007

Sorry it’s been so long since posting anything. It’s been a little more hectic the past few weeks for some reason.

Anyways, I thought I’d write a little bit about why I’ve decided to go ahead and pursue an M.A. degree from Luther Seminary.

  • Desire. Since my junior year in college I have planned on going to seminary someday.
  • Timing. Since my wife Alicia is currently a medical student, she is studying constantly. No joke. If she home and awake, she is studying. Since she is busy studying, I don’t want to do things that bug her, so I usually read. So far this year, I have completed 35 books. I might as well apply that time towards a degree.
  • Flexibility. I don’t want to be a full-time student right now, so I need a degree program that will allow me to work at Hope and complete the degree program. There are no decent part-time M.Div. programs out there, so I am left to get an M.A. right now. Luther has a 4-year distance education program to obtain an M.A. in Youth and Family Ministry. It takes 18 courses, half of which are completed online. The other half are completed on-campus in St. Paul, MN during one- or two-week intensive courses.
  • Diversity. From what I can tell, there are really only two degree programs worth my time that fit my need to be a part-time student: Huntington College and Luther Seminary. I went to college at an evangelical university and thought that a mainline seminary experience might be a good change of pace (Huntington is an evangelical school). And, it seems like the Huntington degree is drinking more of the YouthSpecialites Kool-Aid. I love YouthSpecialties and what they do (and are trying to do) for youth ministry, but youth ministry has grown very homogeneous as a result of the YS influence. Luther seems to be going a different direction. Some diversity would be good.
  • Current context. I’m at a Lutheran church right now (and hope to be for a while), so I might learn some nuances of ministry in the ELCA while being at Luther. However, I don’t plan on being a Lutheran my whole life. Who knows, one day I might be a Presbyterian (there is hope, Dr. C).
  • Faculty. This is the real kicker for me. There are two main professors that drew me to Luther: Rollie Martinson and Andrew Root. Martinson is a youth ministry stalwart. He’s been doing this stuff for about twice as long as I’ve been alive. I’m still trying to wrap my brain around the implications of the Exemplary Youth Ministry study, a project directed by Martinson. I just hope he doesn’t retire before I get a chance to have a few classes with him. Andrew Root is new to the scene, but boy is he making an entrance. His first book, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry, just came out, and it is weighty. It could really change the way we do and think about youth ministry. Everything I’ve read by Root has been pure gold. He’s probably the first of a crop of new youth ministry professors that will come over the next few years. These two guys are the real reasons I want to go to Luther.

I know it seems a little more than coincidental that I’m going to a Lutheran Seminary while working at a Lutheran church. But honestly, I really think I’d be pursuing this degree from this seminary no matter what church I was working at. I really think they offer the best experience for me right now.

My first class in in January (cold!) with Andrew Root. I’m pretty stoked.

Comments (1)
Categories : Christianity, Personal, Seminary, Youth Ministry

Halo 3

By Matt · Comments (7)
Wednesday, October 10th, 2007

I love it when theologically astute people comment on youth ministry issues. D.W. Congdon, Princeton M.Div. Student, has commented on the recent NY Times article about youth ministries using Halo 3 to attract a crowd. Good thoughts. A quote:

If a church wants to be relevant to teenage boys, there are plenty of other ways, including handing out pornography and offering beer-on-tap. You could throw in condoms and cigarettes and call it a night. But this raises an important questions: Why Halo 3? Why are exceedingly violent video games par for the course, but bare breasts on a piece of paper completely out of the question? One could easily argue that the video games are the more harmful of the two. All of this leads us back to the same basic problem with American Christianity: we are prudes about sex, but connoisseurs of violence.

Link.

[UPDATE:] As Robby points out, Ben Witherington is discussing this on his blog as well. He has two posts. Check them out here and here.

[UPDATE 2:] While I’m at it, Tim Schmoyer has a Halo 3 post as well.

Comments (7)
Categories : Christianity, Ecclesiology, Theology, Youth Ministry

Prayer and Capitalism

By Matt · Comments (0)
Tuesday, October 2nd, 2007

There’s a great post over at Inhabitatio Dei. An excerpt:

[I]n the actual practice of making decisions and establishing agendas and practices in Christian ministries today, it is the flow of money or its absence that is accorded primal theological significance. How decisions get made regarding the shape and focus of the ministerial life is determined, with next to no exception by the direction in which monetary capital is flowing… What is the significance of this, theologically speaking? What it really shows is that capital functions, at least in the Western evangelical context as an immanent form of divine power and favor. In effect, the flow of capital becomes the divine sign, the Urim and the Thummim that becomes revelatory of the divine will.

These are prophetic words.

Comments (0)
Categories : Christianity, Ecclesiology, Theology

100 Answers in (around) 100 Words

By Matt · Comments (6)
Tuesday, September 25th, 2007

Over at Life in Student Ministry, Tim Schmoyer has a post on “100 blog topics I hope YOU to write.” Well, I’m done.

I have tried to answer every topic with one (different) word. Some are serious, others are tongue-in-cheek. You’ll have to decide for yourself.

  1. How to use Facebook for ministry: Groups.
  2. How to build community among teenagers: Food.
  3. Technology I use in youth ministry: Huh?
  4. How to write Bible study lessons for youth group: Study.
  5. Conversation starters to ask a student you just met: Food?
  6. How to get parents involved in their kids’ lives: Less.
  7. How to handle confrontation: Carefully.
  8. How to teach students with learning disabilities: Patiently.
  9. How to market your events: Don’t.
  10. How to effectively use visual aids in teaching: Google.
  11. How to make time for personal prayer and devotions: Schedule.
  12. How to empower your youth leaders: Space.
  13. How to follow-up with new believers: Facebook.
  14. Using podcasts in youth ministry: Waste.
  15. How to engage students in worship: Example.
  16. How to deal with a suicide in your ministry: Immediately.
  17. Everything a youth worker should know about eating disorders: Watch.
  18. Addressing porn and masturbation at youth group: XXXchurch.com.
  19. How to help parents prepare their students for college: Trip.
  20. Recommended books for every youth worker’s library: Yaconelli.
  21. How teenage girls best relate to each other: Gossip.
  22. How teenage guys best relate to each other: Wrestling.
  23. Teaching students to evaluate their media consumption: Discernment.
  24. How to equip your students to achieve their dreams: Steps.
  25. Sermon presentations versus small group discussion Bible studies: Easy.
  26. Necessary elements for any youth meeting: Jesus.
  27. Balancing youth group events with athletics, homework and jobs: Missional.
  28. How to achieve longevity in youth ministry: Sabbath.
  29. What students need from their youth leaders: Time.
  30. How to take an idea and make it happen: Ask.
  31. How to plan a youth ministry budget: Last-year.
  32. The real influence of celebrities on students: Excessive.
  33. How to change a teenager’s world forever: Care.
  34. Why youth ministers should read their students’ blogs: Spying.
  35. How to evaluate ministry and implement change: S-L-O-W-L-Y.
  36. Addressing sin in your own life: Kill.
  37. How to make youth group visitors feel welcomed: Talk.
  38. How to use the arts in youth group: Worship.
  39. The youth event no one has ever seen: Marathon.
  40. What I wish every Sr. Pastor knew about youth ministry: Transition.
  41. Balancing youth ministry with my personal life: Calendar.
  42. The difference between part-time and full-time youth ministry: Money (not time).
  43. How to fix your mistakes in ministry: Move.
  44. How to develop students to be spiritual leaders: Risk.
  45. When I feel frustrated in ministry: Read.
  46. Youth group strategies for evangelism: Incarnational.
  47. How to come up with creative ideas: Notepad.
  48. How NOT to introduce visitors to the youth group: Hugs.
  49. What every youth worker needs to know about Jr. High students: ADD.
  50. What every youth worker needs to know about Sr. High students: Deep.
  51. How to earn the trust and respect of your Sr. Pastor: Communicate.
  52. How to lead a youth group when you’re the only volunteer: Help.
  53. How to help a student break an addiction: Prayer.
  54. How to teach through a book of the Bible: Quickly.
  55. What youth group students need from each other: Forgiveness.
  56. Internet tools I use for youth ministry: Bloglines.
  57. How to develop a world missions strategy for your youth group: Pick.
  58. How to simplify your life and ministry: Cancel.
  59. The future of youth ministry: Theology.
  60. How NOT to use video in youth ministry: Flashdance.
  61. How to handle the most common youth ministry struggles: Parents.
  62. How to keep God’s Word fresh for teenagers: Passion.
  63. How to work in a church that doesn’t support it’s youth ministry: Leave.
  64. What to do with “God sightings” stories in your youth group: Share.
  65. Tools for working with hurting teenagers: YouthSpecialties.
  66. How to get kids plugged in to God’s Word: Challenge.
  67. Youth ministry topics that need more coverage: Ecclesiology.
  68. How to become a student-led youth group: Failure.
  69. Expectations to hold for any youth worker volunteer: Perfection.
  70. How to turn conversations toward Christ: “Christ.”
  71. How to respond to criticism: “Thanks.”
  72. Ten youth ministry sites I like and why: TimSchmoyer.com
  73. How to work with the hyper-active kid: Exercise.
  74. How to address self-esteem at youth group: Yay!
  75. How to get your kids sharing and contributing to small groups: Force.
  76. A story of how Christ changed my youth group: Bible.
  77. When to let go of a student and trust God take care of the rest: Rebellion.
  78. How to recharge your emotional batteries: Nap.
  79. How youth ministry made me go crazy!: Busy.
  80. How to make the most of a youth group retreat: Plan.
  81. How to shake a student from their apathy for God’s Word: Live.
  82. Things to consider before purchasing a curriculum: Booo.
  83. American youth ministry and how I would change it: Think.
  84. How to give yourself away: No.
  85. How NOT to give advice to a student: “TheBibleSays.”
  86. The top 10 excuses every youth leader makes: Hectic.
  87. The top 10 excuses every youth group student makes: Soccer (or football, band, etc.)
  88. How to settle a disagreement with your Sr. Pastor: Lose.
  89. Common mistakes to avoid in youth ministry: Burnout.
  90. Guidelines to follow for selecting new youth leaders: Opportunity.
  91. How to facilitate communication between students and parents: Try.
  92. How to partner with parents in youth ministry: Humbly.
  93. Reaching rural kids versus reaching urban kids: Ha!
  94. How to support a student through difficult times: Embrace.
  95. The #1 best thing you can do for the kids in your youth group: Love.
  96. How to promote an attitude of prayer in daily life: Pray.
  97. How the Internet is changing students’ perspective of community: Weakening.
  98. Why I’m in youth ministry today: Teens.
  99. A passage of scripture every student should know: Many.
  100. How to get students involved in the rest of the church body: Integrate.
Comments (6)
Categories : Christianity, Random, Youth Ministry

Kevin Vanhoozer on Youth Ministry

By Matt · Comments (1)
Saturday, September 22nd, 2007

Okay, well, he doesn’t exactly comment on youth ministry. But in an interview at The Exiled Preacher, Vanhoozer is asked about the pastor’s task as theologian. I’ve argued elsewhere that a youth minister has a similar theological responsibility, and think there are obvious parallels.

Guy Davies: In the Drama of Doctrine, you suggested that the theologian is a “dramaturge”, whose task is to enable the pastor -director to understand the biblical script. But not all pastors make time read great works of theology. They are too busy preparing sermons, visiting their people, organising the church’s evangelistic programme and so on. Why should pastors make the effort to become pastor-theologians?

Kevin Vanhoozer: Both parts of the Great Commission, evangelism and making disciples, require theology. Theology is a form of the ministry of the Word; specifically, theology is a the ministry of Christian understanding. We need theology in our evangelism because theology is about preserving the integrity of the word, the message of the gospel an evangelist proclaims. We need theology in our disciple making because theology is about reminding us who we are and what we are to say and do as followers of Jesus Christ in this or that situation.

The world is filled with therapists and managers. What the church needs now is people who can (1) articulate from the Bible the truth about God, the world, and ourselves in terms that are faithful to the Bible and intelligible in the contemporary context (2) exhort their congregations to say and do things that corresponds to the truth of Jesus Christ as attested in the Bible.

Comments (1)
Categories : Christianity, Neo-Youth Ministry, Theology, Youth Ministry

In good company

By Matt · Comments (2)
Tuesday, September 18th, 2007

As I’ve said before, I believe that ecclesiology is the number one problem facing youth ministry (and the church) today.

It seems I am in good company. In my inbox today was the monthly E-Journal from Fuller Seminary’s Center for Youth and Family Ministry (All youth ministers should subscribe to this and actually read it). One of this month’s articles is “Why Ecclesiology? Imagining a New Theology of Youth Ministry for the Church”. A quote:

Getting to the point, the way we think about church profoundly shapes the way we do youth ministry… We each hold a particular view of “church” that permeates our lives and ministries, with each view creating particular questions, opportunities and challenges.

Link.

Comments (2)
Categories : Christianity, Ecclesiology, Youth Ministry

The Covenant of YHWH and the Death of Jesus

By Matt · Comments (1)
Friday, August 31st, 2007

Warning: possible heretical thoughts may follow. What follows isn’t exactly a deeply held dogmatic belief (in fact, I would say I don’t even believe it), but something that has been rolling around in my head for a few years. It is more the outworking of theological creativity and imagination. I have read fairly widely over the past few years and have not found anyone even suggest the following interpretation of the death of Jesus, so I am reluctant to push this without further investigation. With that disclaimer, here we go.

I remember as a sophomore in college sitting in my Old Testament Book Study and Hermeneutics class and listening to Professor Blankenship emphasizing Genesis 15 as the sealing of the covenant YHWH made with Abram. In the passage, Abram took a heifer, goat, ram, dove and pigeon, and cut the larger animals in half. The halves of the animals were arranged opposite of each other and “a smoking firepot with a blazing torch appeared and passed between the pieces”, the smoking firepot understood to represent YHWH. So, YHWH was the only one who covenanted with Abram and walked through the animal pieces, effectively saying, “If I break this covenant, may the fate that fell upon these animals fall upon me”. This is usually interpreted somewhere along the lines of: YHWH was the only one who binded himself to the covenant because he knew that Israel could not uphold their side of the covenant, and God cannot break a promise, thus this is a covenant of grace. God is binding himself to the covenant while knowing that Israel cannot keep up its side.

However, fast forward to Jesus of Nazareth. As Jurgen Moltmann puts it, we find the “crucified God”. In Jesus, did YHWH so change his covenant with his people that in order to establish a new covenant (Luke 22:20) he must face the penalty of breaking the old covenant? Or did YHWH do something prior to the crucifixion that broke the covenant? Can this reading fit in with scripture? Can it complement or does it supplant traditional atonement theories? Does this reading mean the Old Testament is irrelevant for anything other than understanding the New Testament? Did the death of Jesus inaugurate a drastically new covenant that is not the fulfillment of the law in terms of the promise YHWH, but it fulfills the law in terms of the penalties due to YHWH?

Does it not appear in scripture that things often don’t go according to YHWH’s plans? The fall of man, the flood, the disobedience of Israel? Rather than killing the whole world as in Genesis 7, is Jesus YHWH’s way of trying a new plan? Is the roller coaster of fidelity, disobedience, exile, and return in the life of Israel the outworking of YHWH trying to remain faithful to the covenant with Abram without encountering the penalty of changing the rules?

I find that this reading has a lot of theological possibilities, but I haven’t investigated if it came make any sense whatsoever in relation to the biblical text.

Has anyone read or heard anyone talk of the death of Jesus in such a way?

Comments (1)
Categories : Christianity, Theology

On Jeremiah 29:11

By Matt · Comments (9)
Friday, August 24th, 2007

Maybe I’ll start a series sometimes on the most mis-interpreted verses of the Bible. For now, I would like to begin with Jeremiah 29:11. We see this probably most of all around high school graduation time. College graduation probably takes second place, since the kids who were Christians at high school graduation aren’t anymore by the time college graduation rolls around:

For I know the plans I have for you,” declares the LORD, “plans to prosper you and not to harm you, plans to give you hope and a future.

I find it unfortunate that people don’t quote the verse before this one. You know, the one where God tells Israel that they have to spend seventy years in Babylon.

Comments (9)
Categories : Christianity, Random

Best Youth Ministry Books: Postmodern Youth Ministry

By Matt · Comments (3)
Wednesday, August 22nd, 2007

Postmodern Youth Ministry by Tony Jones is the book I would recommend to youth ministers if they could just read one youth ministry book. I first read the book in my Foundations and Practices of Youth Ministry class at John Brown University. After the preface to the book there is a page titled, “The Day My World Changed” where Tony tells of a conversation he had with a woman. He was trying to “witness” to her (my words, not his) and brought up the C.S. Lewis tri-lemma: Jesus must be either Lord, liar, or lunatic. The conversation continues:

“Well, I believe he is Lord for you,” came the response.

“I must not have explained myself,” I said. “He claimed not just to be Lord for Tony but for all humanity – in fact, for all creation.”

“That’s fine. I believe that for you, he is Lord of all creation.”

“But he claims to be Lord of all creation for everyone.”

“Okay, for you he’s Lord of all creation for everyone”

After reading that conversation, I realized my presuppositions of youth ministry that I had brought with me into college would need to be modified, at least a little bit. Unknown to me, this book started me down the long road of radically rethinking what it means to be a Christian, do ministry, and be a church. My theology also ended up shifting significantly. For me, this was the book that got the ball rolling.

In the book, Tony sets forth a philosophy of ministry that is sensitive to our current postmodern context. One of the best features of the book is that other authors were asked to comment on the book and their thoughts are in the margins of the book, right alongside the main text. There are comments by Rudy Carrasco, Brad Cecil, Mark Driscoll, Dan Kimball, Brian McLaren, Sally Morgenthaler, Doug Pagitt, Kara Powell, Leonard Sweet, Pete Ward, and Mike Yaconelli. The pseudo-dialogue that this produces is great to observe and think about.

Tony has left the youth ministry scene to some extent, now being the national coordinator of Emergent Village, but he still does a lot of work with youth ministry organizations, denominations, and churches. As of 2006, he was still a staple of the Youth Specialties National Youth Worker Convention. You will be blessed and stretched by reading this book.

More posts on this book to come.

Comments (3)
Categories : Best Youth Ministry Books, Book Reviews, Books, Christianity, Youth Ministry
« Previous Page
Next Page »

Get Site Updates

Add to GoogleAdd to Google Reader

Click here to learn more about site updates

Favorite Posts

  • 10 Things Youth Ministry Needs Less
  • Neo-Youth Ministry Series
  • 13 Reasons Why Seminaries are Irrelevant
  • Issues in Youth Ministry
  • The Next 50 Years of Youth Ministry
  • The 3 Spheres of Youth Ministry
  • The Freedom of Failure
  • A Theology of Geography: Locality and Proximity
  • How I Built a Church Website for Free

Categories

  • Best Youth Ministry Books (6)
  • Blogging (42)
  • Blogroll (1)
  • Book Reviews (17)
  • Books (33)
  • Christianity (52)
  • Ecclesiology (54)
  • emerging church (14)
  • Links (27)
  • Ministry (4)
  • Neo-Youth Ministry (10)
  • News (25)
  • Personal (69)
  • Podcast (4)
  • Quotes (14)
  • Random (43)
  • Seminary (14)
  • Theology (51)
  • Uncategorized (50)
  • Websites (14)
  • Youth Ministry (148)

Archives

MattCleaver.com
Copyright © 2012 All Rights Reserved
Website by Cleaver Solutions