MattCleaver.com
youth ministry, reimagined
  • Home
  • About
  • Contact Me
  • Best Youth Ministry Books
  • Youth Ministry Book Reviews
  • Youth Ministry Blogs

Archive for Book Reviews – Page 2

Review: Francis Chan’s Crazy Love DVD

By Matt · Comments (2)
Tuesday, March 31st, 2009

AltFrancis Chan Crazy Love DVDhough I don’t know very much about Francis Chan, I do know that he seems to be getting a lot of press lately. His recent gig as one of the keynote speakers at the National Youth Workers Convention has also thrust him into the forefront of many youth ministers.

His Crazy Love DVD is supposed to be a companion to his book, which bears the same title, although I did not know that at first. I thought that the DVD was a stand-alone product. He makes reference to the book almost every segment of the DVD.

Format

The DVD is ten chapters long, each chapter averaging about 9 minutes a piece. The DVD is meant to be used as part of a small group study of the book. At the end of each segment Chan asks a question, usually referring back topics covered in the book. To watch this without having read the book made me feel a bit lost at times. The DVD also has a PDF of a discussion guide that you can print off from your computer.

Style

If you are familiar with Rob Bell’s NOOMA videos, Crazy Love has a very similar production quality, which means top-notch. The video images, lighting, transitions, music, and sound are all as good as anyone could want. Of course, style isn’t everything, but it is nice to see a Christian video curriculum that is visually and audibly appealing.

Theme

The ten segments essentially follow Chan throughout his day, starting at the breakfast table and ending with him putting his kids to bed. Along the way, he talks about different stories and points that relate to the chapters in his book. Though the production style of Chan’s video is very similar to Rob Bells NOOMA videos, Crazy Love has less symbolism and thought-provoking material going on in the background of the video. The obvious thrust of the video is the words spoken by Chan. The settings to his monologues are almost extemporaneous.

Theology

As I stated above, I am quite unfamiliar with Chan, so all of my observations are based solely on this DVD. That being said, Chan appears to come from a more conservative end of the theological spectrum, which will be fitting for those churches who are a bit skeptical about using resources from Rob Bell (I’m not one of them, but I know they are out there). He talks a lot about personal devotions and growing one’s personal relationship with God in the first half or so of the videos.

Towards the end, Chan talks a good amount about what it means to be missional, which is an area where he leaves many of the traditional conservative ways of doing things. He talks about giving up your possessions for one another, opening your home for people to actually live with you, and dropping everything for the sake of the gospel. The end is a good balance of action to complement the prior emphasis on devotion.

Using it in Youth Ministry

As someone in youth ministry, I always try to think through how things would work in my youth ministry, so here are some thoughts:

  • Read the book alongside the DVD. Watching the DVD by itself won’t have the impact of using it as a tool alongside the book.
  • Use it with high school. I’m not sure what the target audience is of Crazy Love, but it seems to be geared for adults. Mature high school students would probably enjoy it, though. I have a girl in my youth group reading the book and she loves it.
  • Don’t use this with small groups who are not already trusting of and familiar with one another. The material is designed to be used in small groups, but some of the material hits really close to home. Chan asks the groups to discuss times in their life when people have died (and what regrets they left behind) and when you have doubted your own salvation, among other things. Such questions are not meant for strangers to discuss among themselves, in my opinion, and especially with teenagers. Without a certain level of intimacy and boundaries in a youth small group, some of these questions could open one up to a high degree of pain if handled incorrectly by immature group members.

Should You Buy It?

In the final estimation, you should first buy Chan’s book Crazy Love. If after reading it you think it would be good material for guiding your small groups, then I would use the DVD to accompany the book. Each segment in the DVD is only about nine minutes long, so the bulk of your time is spent in small group discussion, not watching the screen. The DVD is just a helpful guide, but does not stand well on its own.

Comments (2)
Categories : Book Reviews, Youth Ministry
Tags : Crazy Love, DVD, Francis Chan

Book Review: Awakening Youth Discipleship

By Matt · Comments (0)
Sunday, September 14th, 2008

Awakening Youth Discipleship: Christian Resistance in a Consumer CultureI recently reviewed the book Awakening Youth Discipleship: Christian Resistance in a Consumer Culture (by Brian J. Mahan, Michael Warren, and David F. White) for Youth Ministry Exchange.  You can read the review here.

It’s a good, short (120ish pages) book.  Well worth your time.

Comments (0)
Categories : Book Reviews

Book Review: All the Ideas Living in My Head: One Guy’s Musings About Truth by Don Everts

By Matt · Comments (0)
Saturday, May 17th, 2008

All the Ideas Living in My Head: One Guy’s Musings About Truth[This review is also published at Youth Ministry Exchange.]

As someone who has been in ministry on college campuses since 1994 through InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, Don Everts is no stranger to ideas. College campuses are breeding grounds for dialogue, debate, idea sharing, and general philosophizing. It wasn’t until having an email conversation about the nature of the authority of scripture that Everts really began thinking about his thinking. All the Ideas Living in My Head: One Guy’s Musings About Truth is a tour through Everts’ mind and how he approaches thinking about thinking.

Though the book is subtitled as containing musings about truth, the focus of the topic is not necessarily about truth, but ideas. Everts explains that the way he approaches his thought does not fit into the traditional modern and postmodern categories. He describes modernism as understanding ideas as objective facts and postmodernism approaching ideas as subjective experiences. For Everts, the best way to understand his thinking is by thinking of his ideas as people living in his head. His ideas take on their own personality, new ideas must dialogue with current residents in his head, and ideas eventually develop a seniority based on a wide range of factors.

I found myself nodding along as Everts described what he understood to be happening to the differing ideas that found their way into his head. The book is a short and quick read at only seventy-two pages. The books takes a popular tone that uses plain language to describe some fairly provocative ideas. At times I found myself hearing echoes of Donald Miller in Everts’ style.

Though the book is already brief, it could stand a bit more tightening. Thoughts in the book seemed to be repeated often as they are approached from a few different angles. For those in youth ministry, Everts offers what seems to me to be an acceptable way of talking to our students about the way we think, although his ideas are not explicitly Christian. As he states in the beginning of the book, they are simply his thoughts about the nature of his thinking. If you are interested in a book that offers Christian thoughts on certain topics, you might try one of the other three books in this series. The other books appear to take a closer look at three of the ideas that “live” in his head: the Bible, evil and hell, and tolerance. Though I haven’t read those books yet, I would expect that they would exhibit an explicitly Christian way of thinking about those topics.

Don Everts is an engaging writer, but the repetitive nature of this particular topic seemed to limit the display of his talent. The book offers a fun, easy read on the way in which Everts’ mind functions, which is probably similar to many of his readers. However, there is nothing groundbreaking or thought provoking that would make this a must-read for those in youth ministry. If the topic interests you, you will likely enjoy the book.

Comments (0)
Categories : Book Reviews, Books
Tags : Don Everts, ideas, truth

Revisiting “Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry”

By Matt · Comments (0)
Thursday, November 15th, 2007

Yesterday, I posted on Andrew Root’s brand-new book, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry. I spoke with pretty high regard for the book, saying,

While reading the book, I came to the realization that, to my knowledge, there is no youth ministry book that is as theologically deep and rich as Root’s. Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster’s book The Godbearing Life is the only work close to Root’s in nature, but even it does not probe the depths of a particular theological subject like Root’s. In my estimation, Root’s book will be noted as being the first in a line of theological books written specifically for the context of youth ministry. With the publication of this book, a new (and needed) genre has been birthed.

Creating a new genre isn’t bad for a first book.

The reason this book excites me so much is that I believe this book is an eschatalogical event (okay, that might be a little bit of a stretch). Let me explain. Over a year ago I predicted that the next 50 years of youth ministry would see the theologizing of youth ministry. I said, among other things,

This is why I say that the theologization of youth ministry in the next 50 years will determine whether or not it will live or die. In order to be faithful to the gospel, and not bound to success, we must be able to discern when we are being faithful and when we are neutering the gospel. Among other things, theology is the practice of discernment. For those who are called as professional youth ministers, we must possess within us the ability to perceive the theological implications of everything that we do. Instead of seeing the goal and achieving it with any means possible, we must determine whether or not our means is theologically sound as well.

Yes, I do think I made that “theologization” word up.

For me, Root’s book is the expectation of the future coming to pass in the present. With Root’s book we are making the turn towards a new paradigm in youth ministry.

Yes, the book is a bit difficult to read for some; it is truly a theological work. Yes, we want to ask “but will this work?” Yes, sometimes it seems like there is a bit of practicality missing from the book.

But the reason this book might be so uncomfortable, so challenging, so unfamiliar, and so overwhelming for many of us is that we are reading it while still operating out of the current paradigm of ministry while Root is coming to the table with a completely different set of presuppositions. We would do well to listen to it diligently, since it will be our tendency to try and fit the book into our current paradigm. But to do so would be to lose the weight of the book.

This is the first book to my knowledge that is doing real theology for the sake of youth ministry. But I don’t believe it will be the last. The future of youth ministry is upon us.

Comments (0)
Categories : Best Youth Ministry Books, Book Reviews, Books, Christianity, Neo-Youth Ministry, Theology, Youth Ministry

Best Youth Ministry Books: Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry

By Matt · Comments (6)
Wednesday, November 14th, 2007

With the publication of his first book, Revisiting Relational Youth Ministry: From a Strategy of Influence to a Theology of Incarnation, Andrew Root has stormed onto the youth ministry scene as a force to be reckoned with. Root is Assistant Professor of Youth and Family Ministry at Luther Seminary, which is also home to youth ministry stalwart Rollie Martinson. Root has a background in youth ministry through church work, Young Life, and as a gang prevention counselor. Though he is young, he is theologically astute, graduating from Princeton Theological Seminary with a Ph.D. in Practical Theology.

In his book, which appears to be a reworking of his doctoral dissertation, Root blows open the traditional conception of relational youth ministry as a tool used to gain the right to speak influence in the lives of teenagers. Root thinks this is theologically void and calls it a way of practicing the theological heresy of docetism. Drawing from research conducted while a doctoral student at Princeton Theological Seminary, Root found that in youth ministries, “relationships have been used for cultural leverage (getting adolescents to believe or obey) rather than as the concrete location of God’s action in the world.” This popular strategy of ministry is often touted as incarnational, because this seems to be the way in which Jesus conducted ministry. Root goes on to say,

I have realized that a youth ministry of influence has very little to do with the incarnation…. God became human to be with and for us, not simply to influence us toward this or that end. (This would actually be there heresy of docetism, which believed that Jesus only appeared to be human in order to influence us.)… The incarnation is not about influence but accompaniment.

For the bulk of the book, Root forges a new genre in the niche of youth ministry literature as he constructs a theological treatise for robust incarnational youth ministry, drawing almost exclusively from the theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer. He seeks to answer three questions and show their relevance to youth ministry: Who is Jesus Christ? Where is Jesus Christ? What then Shall We Do? As I told Rusty and Noah the other day, his book could be subtitled something like “If Dietrich Bonhoeffer did Youth Ministry.”

Root does not simply leave his method to intellectual theological arguments, but gives us a final chapter on what this might look like in real youth ministries. His suggestions and theological insights, if taken to heart, really do have the potential to change youth ministry as we know it.

While reading the book, I came to the realization that, to my knowledge, there is no youth ministry book that is as theologically deep and rich as Root’s. Kenda Creasy Dean and Ron Foster’s book The Godbearing Life is the only work close to Root’s in nature, but even it does not probe the depths of a particular theological subject like Root’s. In my estimation, Root’s book will be noted as being the first in a line of theological books written specifically for the context of youth ministry. With the publication of this book, a new (and needed) genre has been birthed.

This is truly a must-read book. Root’s gift to the youth ministry community is not only in the content he provides, but also in modeling for us what it looks like to think theologically about youth ministry. Taking both to heart will change for the better the way you do and think about youth ministry. In fact, this book is helpful in forging a Neo-Youth Ministry.

Comments (6)
Categories : Best Youth Ministry Books, Book Reviews, Youth Ministry

Best Youth Ministry Books: Postmodern Youth Ministry

By Matt · Comments (3)
Wednesday, August 22nd, 2007

Postmodern Youth Ministry by Tony Jones is the book I would recommend to youth ministers if they could just read one youth ministry book. I first read the book in my Foundations and Practices of Youth Ministry class at John Brown University. After the preface to the book there is a page titled, “The Day My World Changed” where Tony tells of a conversation he had with a woman. He was trying to “witness” to her (my words, not his) and brought up the C.S. Lewis tri-lemma: Jesus must be either Lord, liar, or lunatic. The conversation continues:

“Well, I believe he is Lord for you,” came the response.

“I must not have explained myself,” I said. “He claimed not just to be Lord for Tony but for all humanity – in fact, for all creation.”

“That’s fine. I believe that for you, he is Lord of all creation.”

“But he claims to be Lord of all creation for everyone.”

“Okay, for you he’s Lord of all creation for everyone”

After reading that conversation, I realized my presuppositions of youth ministry that I had brought with me into college would need to be modified, at least a little bit. Unknown to me, this book started me down the long road of radically rethinking what it means to be a Christian, do ministry, and be a church. My theology also ended up shifting significantly. For me, this was the book that got the ball rolling.

In the book, Tony sets forth a philosophy of ministry that is sensitive to our current postmodern context. One of the best features of the book is that other authors were asked to comment on the book and their thoughts are in the margins of the book, right alongside the main text. There are comments by Rudy Carrasco, Brad Cecil, Mark Driscoll, Dan Kimball, Brian McLaren, Sally Morgenthaler, Doug Pagitt, Kara Powell, Leonard Sweet, Pete Ward, and Mike Yaconelli. The pseudo-dialogue that this produces is great to observe and think about.

Tony has left the youth ministry scene to some extent, now being the national coordinator of Emergent Village, but he still does a lot of work with youth ministry organizations, denominations, and churches. As of 2006, he was still a staple of the Youth Specialties National Youth Worker Convention. You will be blessed and stretched by reading this book.

More posts on this book to come.

Comments (3)
Categories : Best Youth Ministry Books, Book Reviews, Books, Christianity, Youth Ministry

Book Review at YMX: Choosing Church

By Matt · Comments (0)
Sunday, February 18th, 2007

Since I have a desire to do some writing, I decided a good place to start would be reviewing books. I chose to submit a book review to Youth Ministry Exchange (YMX) and they decided to publish it! Now, I know this isn’t a super-big deal or anything, but it’s neat to see your name on a website that you visit regularly.

This was my first time to submit my writing to a publisher that “reserves the right to edit an author’s work”, so I was interested to see what editorial changes they might make (I know I’ve mixed up a lot of my comma rules, so I was worried about that). Some of the changes I like, others I don’t, but it’s probably just personal preference more than anything. Regardless, I’m thankful to YMX for offering such a platform for ministry. Perhaps I will become a regular contributor.

Below is the original review I submitted. You can find the review on the YMX site here.

In Choosing Church Carol Lytch, a Presbyterian minister, sociologist, and theological educator, seeks to discover what factors keep students attending church through their senior year of high school. In a time when other research shows the steep decline in church attendance among teens as they age such a project is all the more appropriate.

Lytch conducted her research as she pursued her Ph.D., and she later turned it into a book accessible to parents and church leaders. Lytch chose to conduct her research qualitatively, immersing herself in the life of three congregations (one Catholic, one mainline, and one evangelical) with exceptional records of high school seniors’ attendance and participation. Her data is comprised primarily of observations made while participating with the various churches and interviewing teens and parents face-to-face. As can be expected in Ph.D. research, the style and language can be dense and technical at times.

Lytch approaches her research as a sociologist, not necessarily a pastor or theologian. She attempts to find correlations between teen participation in congregations and various factors in the teens, their families, and their congregations. She leaves it up to those who work with teens within churches to take her findings and decide what the data may mean for their particular congregations.

For Lytch, one of the significant factors in congregations in America today is the rise of “personal autonomy, with its guiding motto, ‘I choose to go to church’ rather than ‘I must go to church’” (5). Lytch finds that while this prevalence of personal autonomy might be a barrier to teen church participation, churches and families that do their best to take advantage of this personal autonomy produce teens who believe that their faith is their personal decision and not simply the passing on of religious tradition.

Multiple conclusions are drawn from the mass of data collected, but the number one predictor of a teen’s intention to continue attending church past high school is the “maintenance of a shared family understanding: ‘In our family, we attend church’”(200). This is yet another study that shows that parents are still the most important factor in the Christian formation of young people. Another statement which Lytch ties to parenting has telling implications for youth ministry: “A church may have a vital youth program, and/or the teen may attend an effective religious school, but those involvements appear to be secondary in importance to the teen’s engagement in the church’s weekly gathering for worship” (188).

In a well-researched and relatively comprehensive study, Carol Lytch offers youth workers, especially those willing to wade through some dense and technical language, valuable insights into discipling young people through, and even past, high school.

Comments (0)
Categories : Book Reviews, Books, Christianity, Youth Ministry
« Previous Page

Get Site Updates

Add to GoogleAdd to Google Reader

Click here to learn more about site updates

Favorite Posts

  • 10 Things Youth Ministry Needs Less
  • Neo-Youth Ministry Series
  • 13 Reasons Why Seminaries are Irrelevant
  • Issues in Youth Ministry
  • The Next 50 Years of Youth Ministry
  • The 3 Spheres of Youth Ministry
  • The Freedom of Failure
  • A Theology of Geography: Locality and Proximity
  • How I Built a Church Website for Free

Categories

  • Best Youth Ministry Books (6)
  • Blogging (42)
  • Blogroll (1)
  • Book Reviews (17)
  • Books (33)
  • Christianity (52)
  • Ecclesiology (54)
  • emerging church (14)
  • Links (27)
  • Ministry (4)
  • Neo-Youth Ministry (10)
  • News (25)
  • Personal (69)
  • Podcast (4)
  • Quotes (14)
  • Random (43)
  • Seminary (14)
  • Theology (51)
  • Uncategorized (50)
  • Websites (14)
  • Youth Ministry (148)

Archives

MattCleaver.com
Copyright © 2012 All Rights Reserved
Website by Cleaver Solutions